Old Mill Elementary School, Heber City

The short answer

Old Mill Elementary is a public elementary school serving grades PreK to 5 in the Wasatch County School District, on the east side of Heber City. It is the district’s largest and highest-scoring elementary, ranking among the top schools in Utah, with roughly 80 percent math and 70 percent reading proficiency on recent testing. Under the district’s current pattern, Old Mill students move on to a Wasatch County middle school, then Wasatch High School for grades 9 to 12.

Old Mill Elementary School, 1600 E 980 S, Heber City, UT 84032. Wasatch County School District.

Search Homes in the Old Mill Elementary Area

How good is Old Mill Elementary?

Old Mill Elementary is the standout among Wasatch County’s elementary schools. On recent state testing, roughly 80 percent of students scored proficient in math and 70 percent in reading, well above the statewide average, and the school ranks among the very top elementary schools in Utah. It holds a 7 out of 10 GreatSchools rating and a student to teacher ratio around 19 to 1.

It is also the district’s largest elementary, which reflects both the fast growth on the east side of Heber and the school’s popularity with families.

Where Old Mill Elementary feeds

Old Mill sits at the start of the Heber Valley progression. The district’s elementary schools feed its two middle schools by boundary, and those send students on to Wasatch High School:

• Elementary: Old Mill Elementary, grades PreK to 5
• Middle: Rocky Mountain Middle School or Timpanogos Middle School, grades 6 to 8
• High: Wasatch High School, grades 9 to 12

Because Wasatch County is opening new schools and redrawing lines as the valley grows, treat any middle or high school pairing as a starting point, not a guarantee. Confirm your exact assignment with the Wasatch County School District. You can also explore the wider market on our Heber City area page.

Homes in the Old Mill Elementary area

The area around Old Mill is east Heber City, one of the fastest-growing sides of the valley, with newer subdivisions built out over the past decade and more on the way. Expect newer single-family homes and townhomes, along with some larger properties on the benches toward the mountains.

Because this side of Heber is growing quickly, the mix of active listings shifts month to month. Rather than quote a range that goes stale, we would rather pull a current, address-specific snapshot for you.

Search Homes in the Old Mill Elementary Area

A local broker’s take

If schools are steering your Heber search, Old Mill is the easy favorite: top-tier state scores, a strong reputation, and a location on the growing east side where much of the newer housing is. The tradeoff is demand, both for the school and the homes around it, so inventory moves fast. Because Wasatch County lines shift as new schools open, confirm the boundary before you count on Old Mill for a given address. When you find a home you like, we will do exactly that before you write an offer.

Explore the wider market on our Heber City area page, or see where Old Mill students head next on our Rocky Mountain Middle School and Timpanogos Middle School pages.

Enrolling and location

Families within the boundary receive guaranteed enrollment. Utah’s open enrollment policy allows applications from outside the boundary, subject to available space, through the Wasatch County School District. Because Old Mill is popular and the district is rezoning, out-of-boundary spots can be limited, so apply early and confirm the assignment for your address.

When you are ready to find a home in the Heber Valley, call 801-999-8005 or reach out here, and we will pull current listings inside the boundary and confirm the attendance area on any address you are considering.

Sources: GreatSchools, SchoolDigger, Niche, U.S. News and World Report, PublicSchoolReview, KPCW, the Wasatch County School District, and live listing data from zoomUTAH. School data reflects the most recent published figures and changes over time, and Wasatch County boundaries shift as new schools open, so verify any specific address before relying on it.